ARC Review: Artemis, by Andy Weir

Artemis Andy Weir

EDIT [2018/09/19]:

Rating: ★★★☆☆

I’m deducting a star from my original rating because, upon reflection since I read the book, I realized that the things that bothered me about this book are more important than I initially thought.  I truly didn’t like how Jazz was written and, to quote from a few reviews, she’s more like a stereotypical thriller/sci-fi guy, but with breasts. She’s not written as a woman, really, and while I didn’t mind the lack of women in The Martian so much, it bothered me that Artemis seemed to try to make up for it in such a way.

ORIGINAL REVIEW:

Rating: ★★★★☆

Genres: Science Fiction, Thriller

Goodreads Amazon 

I have received this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Jazz is a criminal – she makes deliveries and some of those are – well, less than legal. After a falling out with her father, she lives in an awful, tiny place in the only city in the Moon – Artemis. When she fails her EVA master test, she needs to start saving all over again to buy a new suit and be able to get a better job. But then, she’s offered a million for doing a dangerous job. It’s risky and she’s never done a heist before, but with that kind of money, all her problems would be gone. But her job is far more dangerous to her and the city than she knows.

Artemis is a sci-fi novel for sci-fi lovers. Although this is a thriller and has a heist story, plus it’s set on the moon, and The Martian was such a nice read with genre-cross appeal, Artemis is not that easy for readers who don’t like sci-fi. It’s a bit heavier on the technological side and has plenty of chemistry which I suppose it’s easy to skim through, but you miss part of the story that way.

If you do like sci-fi, you’ll really enjoy this novel!

At first, Jazz’s voice felt to me a little too movie-like, a little too much like the author was trying to write a cool female character and tended to overdo it a bit, turning her into the main character from The Martian, jokes and all. It sounded artificial and she definitely felt like a woman written by a man. But as the novel goes on, Jazz really grew on me and, by the end, I very much liked her! She is sarcastic, very intelligent and full of confidence and scheming. I also loved that she’s Arab!

I wasn’t too big a fan of the Brazilian representation in this novel – they were, like Jazz, too much of a caricature for me. I tried to overlook it and told myself it was cool to see Brazilians in novels not being just a sexy girl or an expert samba dancer and such. Especially as villains! But they were basically all trained in the streets to be fighters and ruthless and with no morals. As thriller villains all are, I suppose… plus the physical description included “Latina skin”, which is too stereotypical for my taste.

I also didn’t quite like the emails exchanged between Jazz and Kelvin, although it gave insight into what she was like and how the smuggling idea came up etc, it definitely broke the narrative.

The best way to enjoy this novel is not to compare it to The Martian – yes, I know, it’s difficult, but really it’s more enjoyable like that! This is about heist, running against the clock, conspiracy. It has more action than The Martian but lacks its uniqueness, in my opinion. This ended up being a very entertaining and fast read for me, and the idea of a city in the Moon, where you walk with 1/6th of the gravity was quite interesting! I wish there had been a little more world-building in the beginning so it didn’t feel like getting information dumped on you at some parts of the novel.

Sorry for complaining so much, there were just various points in this novel that stopped me from giving it 5 stars. But it was a very enjoyable sci-fi and I read it in one day! I enjoyed the heist story, the sass, the moon setting and the ending very much!

22 thoughts on “ARC Review: Artemis, by Andy Weir

  1. great review naty!!! actually, i was thinking of you while reading this book, because i asked myself what you would thing about the whole brazilian thing. now i know! 🙂
    i really liked jazz from the beginning, because i just like sarcastic, sassy characters haha 😀
    i am glad you enjoyed it all in all. the only thing for me was, that i could not NOT compare it to “the martian”, since that is one of my favorite books. but i still enjoyed “artemis” immensly!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Alex!! Yes, it was difficult to come to a conclusion about the Brazilian representation! As much as I love having a different representation as a villain, I didn’t like the whole “latina skin tone” and such thing…

      Yeah it’s quite difficult not to compare them both, but I found I enjoyed Artemis more when I could put my mind off comparing them… I think it might be easier if one has read The Martian a long time ago, as I read it just a few months ago, it’s still rather fresh in my mind…

      Liked by 1 person

  2. This is a really good review, and I don’t think you’re complaining too much. I mean, obviously you liked the book because you gave it 4 stars. All of your comments seem completely valid.

    Seeing everyone talking about Andy Weir’s new book just reminds me that I still need to read The Martian. I own it; I just need to find the time to fit it into my reading schedule.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Danielle! It’s always so much easier to find fault in a book, and the positive things always seem so generic to say… (entertaining, fun, well written…) I’m glad I didn’t come off as too picky! 🙂

      The Martian is pretty good! I hope you enjoy it once you can pick it up. My reading schedule for December is so packed, oh my god…

      Like

  3. Yeah Jazz definitely grew on me too. I totally get what you mean about not comparing it to the Martian. And it’s a shame about the representation. I totally get why you focused on a lot of these things- sometimes there’s just a lot of niggling reasons why a book just about missed out on 5*. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Pingback: The Sunday Snuggle Week 38 2018 | Naty's Bookshelf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s